Three Waters Resort and Marina
Best for travelers who want many on-site restaurants, bars, water-sports options and a full-service marina.
Hotel comparison guide
Three Waters Resort and Marina vs La Siesta Resort & Villas
Three Waters Resort and Marina is an amenity-rich, family-friendly Islamorada resort with multiple pools, restaurants, and a full-service marina; read this if you want wide on-site dining, boating, and multi-generation options. La Siesta Resort & Villas is an Islamorada waterfront property with villa-style guestrooms and a quieter, cottage feel; read this if you’re comparing a smaller villa property to Three Waters or prefer a more residential layout.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart
La Siesta Resort & Villas
Best for travelers who prefer villa-style suites and a quieter, smaller waterfront resort experience.
Quick Verdict: Three Waters Resort and Marina vs La Siesta Resort & Villas
When Three Waters wins: choose Three Waters Resort and Marina if you want a one-stop property with many dining venues (Kindler, Little Limón, Mercado Morada, Tiki Bar, Kokomo swim-up bar, etc.), a full-service 72-slip marina, three year-round pools (including an adults-only Cove), daily resort activities, and easy water-taxi access to sister properties.
When La Siesta wins: pick La Siesta Resort & Villas if you prefer a smaller, villa-style hotel with kitchenettes in many rooms, private beach access, and a lower-key waterfront setting within walking distance of local Islamorada sights.
Bottom line: Three Waters is the choice for amenity variety, boating, and multiple dining options; La Siesta is the calmer, villa-centric alternative. Both sit on the Islamorada waterfront and can suit different trip priorities—amenities and social scene versus simpler villa accommodations.
Three Waters Resort and Marina vs La Siesta Resort & Villas – At a Glance
| Category | Three Waters Resort and Marina | La Siesta Resort & Villas |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort complex with lively dining, marina, and family- and group-focused programming | Smaller, villa-style resort with a more residential, low-key feel |
| Location (Islamorada) | 84001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada (mile marker ~84); waterfront on 15 acres | 80241 Overseas Highway, Islamorada; waterfront property |
| Size (rooms) | 214 rooms, suites, and cottages | 55 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All-ages resort overall; The Cove is a 21+ adults-only enclave | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Three year-round pools (Kokomo, Overseas, Cove adults-only); swim-up bar at Kokomo | Number of outdoor pools - 1 |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (Kindler Wood-Fired Fare, Little Limón rooftop, Mercado Morada, Tiki Bar, Kokomo, Islamorada Pizza Co., Lucky Twist, Starbucks, and more) | Room service (limited hours), poolside bar and a fee breakfast option; fewer on-site restaurants |
| Spa & wellness | Oceanside massages / Ooh La La spa treatments; open-air fitness center and a 21+ Wave Motion Studio | Not published |
| Marina & water access | Full-service marina with 72 slips, fishing charters, water-sports rentals, Rum Runner water taxi to sister properties | |
| Known for | Marina, wide dining selection, multiple pools and beaches, event/wedding venues | Villa-style suites and cottages with kitchenettes and a private beach |
| Parking & transport perks | Self-parking included in nightly resort fee; daily water taxi and shuttle included with resort fee | Free area shuttle; parking info not published in listing |
A Look Inside Three Waters Resort and Marina
See all photos →
Location: Three Waters vs La Siesta
Three Waters Resort and Marina – Location
Three Waters sits on 15 waterfront acres at mile marker 84 with direct marina and beach access.
- Address: 84001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Near Windley Key Fossil Reef and Theater of the Sea (about a 10–15 minute walk to some nearby attractions)
- On-site marina provides direct water access and docking
Choose Three Waters for a central, activity-rich waterfront base with easy boat access.
La Siesta Resort & Villas – Location
La Siesta is a waterfront villa-style resort on Overseas Highway with private beach access.
- Address: 80241 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
- A 4-minute walk from Indian Key Historic State Park per the supplier listing
- Offers a private beach plus a complimentary area shuttle
La Siesta is a quieter waterfront stay within walking distance of local attractions.
Rooms: variety and layout
Three Waters Resort and Marina – Rooms
Three Waters offers 214 rooms, suites, and cottages across many room types, including Cove 21+ options.
- Room types include rooms, junior suites, 1- and 2-bedroom suites and cottages; several listed with oceanfront balconies
- The Cove rooms and suites are reserved for guests 21 and older
- Many rooms accommodate families with sofa beds and multiple-bed configurations
Three Waters gives more room-type choices and larger inventory for families and groups.
La Siesta Resort & Villas – Rooms
La Siesta provides 55 individually decorated guestrooms and suite/cottage layouts, many with kitchenettes.
- Room types include Ocean Front Cottage, OceanFront Casita, Studio Suite Ocean View King, Two Bedroom Suite, and other suite options
- Kitchenettes with refrigerators and microwaves are available in many units
- Rooms are described as individually decorated and cottage-style
La Siesta is a good pick for travelers who want suite or cottage-style accommodations and in-room kitchenettes.
Dining & drinks: range and character
Three Waters Resort and Marina – Dining & drinks
Three Waters has a broad mix of venues from wood-fired dining to a rooftop bar and a swim-up pool bar.
- Signature: Kindler Wood-Fired Fare (breakfast, brunch, dinner)
- Little Limón rooftop offers evening dining with ocean views; Mercado Morada focuses on Central American street food
- Casual options include Tiki Bar (historic Rum Runner origin), Islamorada Pizza Co., Kokomo swim-up bar, Lucky Twist soft-serve, and Starbucks
Pick Three Waters if on-site culinary variety and multiple drinking venues matter.
La Siesta Resort & Villas – Dining & drinks
La Siesta offers limited on-site dining compared with Three Waters and provides cooked-to-order breakfasts for a fee.
- Breakfast available (surcharge) with cooked-to-order options from 7:00 AM to 11:00 AM
- Room service available during limited hours per supplier listing
- Poolside bar and picnic area noted among amenities
La Siesta is better for travelers who plan to eat off-property or want simple on-site dining rather than many restaurant choices.
Pools, beach & signature amenities
Three Waters Resort and Marina – Pools, beach & signature amenities
Three Waters features three year-round pools, multiple beaches including an adults-only Cove, and water-sports rentals.
- Pools: Kokomo (swim-up bar), Overseas Pool, and The Cove Pool (21+)
- Daily resort fee includes bike and kayak/paddleboard rentals plus Rum Runner water taxi access
- Full-service marina (72 slips) supports fishing charters and boat rentals
If multiple pools, a swim-up bar, and marina activities are priorities, Three Waters is the stronger match.
La Siesta Resort & Villas – Pools, beach & signature amenities
La Siesta has a private beach, one outdoor pool, and on-site kayaking and fishing opportunities.
- Private beach access listed in amenities
- Number of outdoor pools: 1
- Amenities include kayaking on site, fishing on site, and bicycles to rent
La Siesta suits guests who want a private beach and light water-activity options without a large resort atmosphere.
Wellness & nightlife: what to expect
Three Waters Resort and Marina – Wellness & nightlife
Three Waters offers oceanside massages, an open-air fitness center, and nightly entertainment options at venues like the Tiki Bar.
- Oceanside Massages / Ooh La La spa treatments available on the beach
- Open-air Outdoor Fitness Center and a 21+ Wave Motion Studio at The Cove
- Live music at Tiki Bar and activity programming across the resort
Three Waters provides both wellness services and on-site evening entertainment.
La Siesta Resort & Villas – Wellness & nightlife
La Siesta’s listing highlights quieter amenities and local walks rather than an on-site spa or lively nightlife.
- 24-hour front desk and well-lit paths to the entrance
- Waterfront setting lends itself to quiet evenings; live nightlife options depend on local Islamorada venues
- On-site offerings include bicycles and a picnic area for casual recreation
Choose La Siesta if you want a low-key stay and will seek nightlife or spa services off-property.
Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style
Three Waters Resort and Marina
Three Waters — multiple signature restaurants, rooftop dining, swim-up bar and casual outlets across the property.
Three Waters Resort and Marina
Three Waters — full-service 72-slip marina and year-round fishing charter access.
La Siesta Resort & Villas
La Siesta — cottage and suite layouts with kitchenettes and individually decorated rooms.
La Siesta Resort & Villas
La Siesta — smaller property footprint and a private beach for lower-key stays.
Frequently asked questions
See all FAQs →Three Waters Resort and Marina vs La Siesta Resort & Villas: FAQs
Which property is better for families?
Three Waters is more family-focused overall, with multiple pools, kids’ activities, an arcade, and family-oriented dining options; La Siesta is smaller and quieter but still accepts children.
Can I get a private boat slip or book fishing charters on-site?
Three Waters has a full-service marina with 72 slips and offers fishing charters; La Siesta lists a marina on site but Three Waters is the primary marina hub in the collection.
Are there adults-only areas?
Three Waters includes The Cove, a 21+ adults-only enclave with its own pool and beach; La Siesta is not an adults-only property.
Do rooms at La Siesta have kitchenettes?
Yes — the supplier listing notes many La Siesta guestrooms include kitchenettes with refrigerators and microwaves.
More Three Waters Resort and Marina Comparison Guides
Explore how Three Waters Resort and Marina stacks up against other hotels nearby:
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Cheeca Lodge & Spa
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Hawks Cay Resort
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Playa Largo Resort & Spa, Autograph Collection
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Islander Resort
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Amara Cay Resort
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Chesapeake Beach Resort
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Lime Tree Bay Resort
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Ocean Pointe Suites at Key Largo
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Waterside Suites & Marina
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Hadley Resort and Marina
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Fisher Inn Resort & Marina
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Hampton Inn Key Largo
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Holiday Inn Key Largo
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Largo Resort
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Bayside Inn Key Largo
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Drop Anchor
- Three Waters Resort and Marina vs Coconut Cove Resort and Marina
- All Three Waters Resort and Marina comparisons
Book your stay
Daily Rum Runner Water Taxi Included
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge